I have become aware of an impending rally in Washington, DC on September 18 in support of the prisoners languishing in Nancy’s Dungeon due to their activities on January 6. I question the wisdom of holding or participating in this rally.
I understand why citizens would rally in support of the prisoners of January 6. I agree that these lengthy (often solitary) incarcerations without charges are deeply problematic and their reported treatment is atrocious. The silence of the Mainstream Media on the subject reflects the asymmetric and hypocritical outrage that has made them among the least trusted American institution after Congress, and is proof of their perfidy and cowardice (as though further proof were needed). Thus, it is natural for some might feel that a rally in DC is called for and the right way to approach this.
One obvious reason to question the wisdom of this rally is that it could easily be a setup. Though I have not been close to this “Nancy’s Dungeon” aspect of our movement, I am close enough to know that this rally did not arise through any organic process of which I am aware. I did not hear people calling for it within the circles I roam. I did not hear groups debating where and how to do this. It was announced out of the blue four weeks ago by Matt Braynard on a podcast with Steve Bannon. As I explained in A message to Militias Across America About Agents Provocateurs (Not the Lingerie), one dimension of political espionage is to get opponents to hold demonstrations that one infiltrates and corrupts (e.g., by getting them to do something violent, thus driving a wedge between them and the public). I am not saying that is the case with the organizers of this rally, but as a guy deeply buried within the movement, I can tell you that this did not bubble up out of any discussions of which I was aware. Like Athena springing full-grown from the forehead of Zeus, this rally just sprang into existence full-grown on a Steve Bannon broadcast. Enough said.
I may be wrong, it may be sincere and not a set-up (though it could still be the case that the organizers are sincere yet it is still a set-up opportunity in the minds of the Goons). There is still a second, less uncertain reason to question the wisdom of holding or participating in this rally in DC this coming Saturday. It is this: Tensions are high and nerves are fraught. Yes you have the right to rally. But people are afraid and this is provocative. Let me compare it to something in my own life: I happen to be tall. There are times I have been walking of an evening and seen people (often women) walking towards me in the gloom, and realized from their body language that they were growing distressed as we neared. If at all possible, I generally make a point to turn and cross away, or if nothing else adopt a body language of humility and respect as we draw close, to dispel their apprehension. It is not that I don’t have a right to walk on that sidewalk and strut as I do it. It is just that it makes people fearful. When young I learned that when people are fearful they behave erratically, and when people behave erratically there are many things that can happen and almost all are bad for me. But it is also because I try to be considerate, and if I am discomfiting strangers (especially women) my instinct is to remedy it. Call me “old fashioned” that way but it seems natural. The September 18 rally in DC for the January 6 prisoners is discomfiting millions of people: perhaps those concerned about the prisoners (and such concern is indeed warranted) could find other ways to make their concern known without scaring millions who already have the jitters.
For these considerations, to anyone planning on going forward with the September 18 rally in DC in support of the January 6 prisoners, I give these two pieces of advice:
- Don’t (but do find other ways to show them support, like donating to their lawyers, or rallying in places outside of DC);
- If you do go, make a heartfelt commitment to refrain from taking part in any mayhem whatsoever. If challenged or insulted, simply walk past the barking dog. If attacked, do not defend yourselves (given that videos will emerge and be distorted). Do not get in fistfights or shoving matches. Do not approach the Capitol building.